cat

Monday, June 13, 2011

Do you love facebook? Would you pay for it?

I'm not starting a rumor, I'm asking a question. How much do you value facebook? I've conducted an informal survey asking friends and family, "If facebook charged you $20/month, would you keep your account?". No one has said yes to that.

Do I hate facebook? Absolutely not, I post pictures of my kids all the time on there for family. I like hearing that extended family who is out of state can keep up with my family.

But, how do you feel about them getting a potential $100 billion valuation?
(Hint, if you were Zuck you'd be smiling too!)


Did you know facebook is losing users? Did you have all sorts of free time to give to facebook before you started using (yes it's a drug and I'm addicted)

Sure their advertising can be both contextual and behavioral but consider these key facts from a Forbes 2001 article:

Key Facts:
• Costs of banner ads are falling, making them increasingly
attractive as compared to traditional print advertisements.
• Opt-in e-mail marketing response rates are falling, while the
cost of lists remains comparatively static.
• Too much emphasis is being placed on measuring clickthrough
and response rates for banner ads and e-mail. View
these forms of marketing as “brand building,” not as a single
measure of success.
• Calculate the cost effectiveness of banner ads only as a way
to compare specific banner ads (on specific Web sites and
page locations) with one another.
• Successful marketing programs require a mix of all
marketing elements, rather than a focus on individual
elements.
Bottom Line: Response and click-through measurements
should be used as indicators to compare the success of similar
online advertising programs with similar marketing schemes,
rather than as a measurement tool against print or other offline
channels. While it is interesting to compare and contrast the cost
differences, it is more important.

Facebooks's main source is online advertising. If suddenly online advertising value was placed at the value me as a consumer places (I rarely even realize it's there I'm so numb to it), would facebook still be potentially worth 100 billion?

My conclusion is that I'd like to see the freemium model available for facebook. I want to be able to pay to get rid of the ads. Am I the first who would admit to being willing to pay $20/month for facebook?

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

You raise some good questions here.

Some of the recent dotcom valuations have been absolutely staggering. Remember the $15-20 billion for Groupon?

But I can see how Facebook definitely rises above the crowd. Though their oft-stated user count of 500,000,000 probably reflects anyone who has ever opened an account, regardless of whether or not they ever use it, they must still have impressive numbers.

I think what makes Facebook stand out is that their active users -- whatever the number -- are very, very engaged. We have photos, memories, exchanges, stored there. It serves as a "lifeline" of sorts to the people in our lives, past and present. Few sites on the Web can claim that level of emotional connection. All that equals great value.

That said, I doubt I'd pay $20/month; perhaps for a whole year though. (But don't tell the Facebook team that...)

Anonymous said...

I think this is a spectacular blog post.

I agree entirely with what Phil posted, in that, while I am an avid "facebooker," I would never pay $20/month to use it. I would agree to the yearly fee of $20.00, but that would indeed rule out any of the users who are not actively using their accounts.

I think a lot of people use the social network to sit back and watch others, rather than post on other profiles everyday. Being that I live in Minnesota but have friends all over the country and world, I use facebook to keep abreast to the happenings in friends' lives.

Facebook does have an emotional connection to its users, but I would say that degree of connection varies greatly between users. Many would willingly ditch their facebook account, and others would protest if they started charging people to use it.

The last thing I will say is that facebook receives most of their revenue from sponsorships, but, I can honestly say that I have not looked at more than 5% of those sponsorships that reside in the margins. Perhaps I have been accustomed to thinking these were useless popups, but I do not pay attention to them. So, if this is going to continue to be the website's strategy of revenue, they may want to research how much they are getting used more thoroughly.

Anonymous said...

Fantastic post on Facebook. I would agree that $20/month would be over the top, although $20/year is more manageable. Although, just like any other annual fee, the cost will just continue to rise. Facebook does get most of their revenue from advertisements and business partnerships. As long as facebook can continue to grow and be consistent, more businesses will continue to support them.

Post a Comment